Rent vs buy calculator.
A rent vs buy reality engine: opportunity cost, maintenance drag, home appreciation, selling costs, and rent growth — the things everyone forgets — all modeled here.
Most people ask whether to rent or buy. You just saw how the answer changes depending on where you live, for how long, and what the market does next.
About the Rent vs. Buy Calculator
The Rent vs. Buy Calculator goes beyond monthly payment comparisons to model the net worth impact of buying a home versus renting and investing the difference. It accounts for property taxes, maintenance, insurance, buying and selling costs, home appreciation, rent growth, and what the down payment would have earned if it stayed invested. The result shows projected net worth for each path over your chosen horizon and the year buying pulls ahead, if it does.
How this rent vs buy calculator keeps score.
A rent vs buy calculator that only compares a mortgage payment to a rent check misses most of the decision. This one tracks two net worth figures over your horizon. The buyer’s is home value minus the remaining mortgage balance minus what it would cost to sell, plus any monthly savings they were able to invest. The renter’s is a portfolio that starts with the down payment and closing costs they never spent, growing at the investment return you set, plus whatever they save each month by paying rent instead of the full cost of owning.
Each year, whichever side pays less in total housing cost invests the difference in their own portfolio. Owning costs include principal and interest on a 30-year fixed loan, property tax, maintenance, and insurance at half a percent of home value. Renting costs the rent, rising every year at the rent-inflation rate you set. The chart draws both net worth lines across the horizon, and the verdict is simply which line is higher at the year you selected, and by how much. A break-even year is reported when buying pulls ahead for good.
A worked example with the default numbers.
Take a $500,000 home with 20% down at a 6.5% rate. Principal and interest on the $400,000 loan is about $2,528 a month. Add property tax at 1.2% ($500 a month), maintenance at 1.5% ($625) and insurance ($208), and owning runs about $3,860 a month before any tax deduction. Against $2,800 rent, the renter starts with roughly $1,060 a month to invest, on top of the $110,000 of down payment and closing costs they kept in the market instead of putting into the house.
That $110,000 alone becomes about $237,000 after ten years at 8%. Meanwhile the house at 4% appreciation is worth about $740,000, but selling it costs about $44,000 in fees, and the buyer still owes most of the mortgage. Whether the buyer wins depends on how those pieces net out, and it is rarely obvious without running it. Rent climbing 3.5% a year reaches about $3,950 a month by year ten. At exactly these default numbers renting stays ahead the whole way: about $33,000 ahead at year ten, and the tool finds no break-even year. Higher appreciation, a lower investment return or a cheaper home relative to rent can flip it, which is why every assumption is a slider.
Which sliders decide the answer.
Transaction costs are the quiet killer of short holds. Two percent to buy and six percent to sell means an eight percent round trip; on a $500,000 home that is $40,000 that has to be recovered through appreciation and rent savings before buying breaks even. This is why the break-even year, not the monthly payment, is the number to watch. Shorten the horizon to three or four years and the renter wins almost every scenario. A longer stay gives the buyer more years to absorb those costs, though at the default assumptions renting still stays ahead. The costs are the same; the time to absorb them is not.
The other three that matter are appreciation, investment return, and maintenance. Set appreciation and return to values you would accept in a mediocre decade rather than a boom, and use a maintenance figure that includes a roof and an HVAC replacement over the period, because realtor math usually ignores both. Then move each slider one notch at a time and watch which one flips the verdict. If a single optimistic assumption is doing all the work, the decision is closer than the chart makes it look.
- Home appreciation: 3–4% is close to long-run averages; 6%+ is a bull-market assumption
- Alternative investment return: what the renter’s portfolio earns — 7–8% nominal for an index fund
- Maintenance: 1–2% of home value per year, higher for older homes
- Selling costs: 5–6% for agent commissions and transfer fees
Frequently Asked Questions
Is buying always better than renting?▼
What is the price-to-rent ratio?▼
What hidden costs does homeownership have?▼
Why does the calculator start the renter with the down payment?▼
Does the model include the mortgage interest deduction?▼
What does the break-even year mean?▼
How should I set the time horizon?▼
Can I model a 15-year mortgage or an adjustable rate?▼
Related Financial Tools
Monthly Budget Calculator
Estimates take-home pay from gross income and splits it across fixed, flexible and future categories to show unallocated dollars, a flexibility index and a tension score; Auto-Optimize is Pro.
Try it freeGeographic Arbitrage Calculator
Compare take-home pay, housing and everyday costs between two U.S. cities, then see how the monthly difference could compound if invested.
Try it freeNet Worth Calculator
Track your net worth, assets, and liabilities with liquidity analysis and momentum tracking.
Try it free